The world of pan, tilt, zoom security cameras has changed. Megapixel cameras and video analytics are shifting the role of PTZs.
PTZ cameras were once king of the hill. They represented the best possible technology you could get; giving you the ability to see in every direction and zoom into the smallest details.
Companies like Pelco, Vicon and Kalatel, to name a few, started their businesses by producing high quality pan, tilt, zoom cameras. They rode the wave, as PTZs defined video surveillance, and grew into leading video companies.
But the problem is that all the power and benefits PTZs deliver are only gained when a person is sitting there actively panning, tilting and zooming. With only a few percent of cameras being actively monitored, and only a few percent of those being watched at one time, there is no one at the helm more than 99% of the time.
The other disadvantage of PTZs is that the moment you’ve zoomed in to see a license plate or to get a close-up of a person’s face, you lose the ability to see everything else. You can easily miss something more important.
If you want to look across a site, PTZs are valuable tools. But if they are sitting there, not being actively driven most of the time, they are expensive cameras. That’s why many PTZs are set for continuous tours, where they move from one preset location to another, auto-panning. This also partly overcomes the problem with missing things when it is zoomed into one area. They move from one point to another to cover a wider area. This allows one expensive camera to cover the whole area. That’s the hope, anyway.
However, belts, gears and motors don’t last long when the PTZ is set for continuous tours. The best quality models need replacement parts every year, when set for auto-panning. Cheaper model PTZs wear out even faster. When that one expensive camera fails at the site, you’ve now got nothing.
Megapixel cameras have taken a big chunk out of the once powerful PTZ. No motors, belts or gears to wear out. Even when you zoom in, you can still keep on recording the whole scene, so you won’t miss anything. This is ideal for recorded video. Megapixel cameras don’t give you anywhere near the full zoom capability of PTZs. You are limited to about 3X-8X for a megapixel zoom, not the 20x-30x you get with a PTZ, but in many cases that’s fine. And, you can buy two megapixel cameras for the price of one PTZ.
Video analytics are also changing the world of PTZs. The applications where PTZs are most important – were live monitoring is needed – that’s exactly where video analytics provide the biggest bang. They enable security personnel to monitor far more cameras much more effectively, by proactively popping up cameras when the analytics see potential threats.
Why not use video analytics with PTZ cameras? You can, and we sell such systems all the time. But if you want to be sure you are going to catch an intruder, you can’t have that PTZ panning all over the place. Fixed cameras are the only way to assure you never miss a threat.
For example, let’s say you have a site where you want one PTZ camera to auto-tour across four different preset locations. The PTZ would move to one preset, watch for some time and then move on to the next. How much time will the camera spend watching any one area? Less than 25% of the time! That means more than 75% of the time you have no visibility on what is happening. With more than four presets, it is even worse. That’s a huge blind spot in your protection!
The alternative: You can put up 3-4 cameras with video analytics built-in for about the same cost as a PTZ camera with analytics, and you won’t have yearly replacement costs for the motors, belts and gears. Most importantly, the analytics won’t miss what is happening – so you get much better security. In fact, it is the only way to go, when you need surefire protection.
In other words, fixed, non-moving cameras with analytics now give the best site awareness. With active video analysis doing the watching for you, it is better to have more fixed smart cameras than a panning PTZ.
So, the new king of the hill is a megapixel camera with analytics built-in. This gives you zoom, a wide area of coverage that is never missed, and analytics to detect potential threats so that you know which camera to be looking at.
Even better, add a PTZ camera at the site if you want the ability to zoom in for a close-up. That’s where the PTZ excels. It’s a tool for extreme close-ups. This combination system has persistent protection because the megapixel cameras continue watching the areas they are trying to protect. They never look the wrong direction. Plus, the analytics watch for threats continuously, even when no one is watching the monitors.
The PTZ will be around for a long time and still plays an important role in surveillance. However, it is not quite as important as it once was. It once was king. Now it is a good soldier. The world has changed for PTZs.
